Printable Book Club Questions for The Night Swim by Megan Goldin

What did you think about the author’s decision to feature a “behind the scenes” look at a true crime podcast? Do you listen to true crime media (podcasts, shows, documentaries)? Do you think they do help to solve cases at times?
Rachel’s previous seasons had focused on past cases but this season is the first time she followed a trial as it’s happening. Why do you think that Rachel chose the Blair trial for season three?
On her way into town, Rachel receives a letter from Hannah, a woman who believes that her sister was murdered 25 years ago. While her producer Pete tells her to ignore it, Rachel decides to investigate it the same time as she covers the trial. Why do you think Rachel was so insistent on finding out what happened to Jenny?
What are some of the similarities between both cases?
Did you trust Hannah or did you have concerns about how easily she was able to get close to Rachel?
What did you think about the coverage of the trial itself?
The two cases feature many of the same people at different stages in life. Did you think it was interesting how it all connected or did you believe it was a bit too convenient?
Most of the people in town believed that Jenny just drowned, despite being a good swimmer. And she also developed a reputation for being “easy.” It’s similar with Kelly where people try to say she was drunk and hooked up with Scott and then regretted it later, which we know both women were assaulted. Why do you think so many people try to victim blame in those situations?
Why do you think Mitch Alkins switched from being a defender to a prosecutor? What did you think about his storyline with Jenny?
Did you have any suspicions about Kelly’s father Dan Moore? Or were you completely surprised when it turned out he was part of the group to assault Jenny and eventually he murdered her?
What did you think about the ending? Do you feel that justice was served in both cases or do you think it wasn’t enough? Do you think Hannah will finally find peace and be able to move forward with her life?
If the author wrote a sequel with Rachel investigating another case, would you read it?