Printable Book Club Questions for The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter

When we first meet Maggie, we know she considers Ethan her nemesis. Why did she hate him so much for so long?
What were your initial thoughts about Ethan? Did that change as the story went on?
Why did Maggie accept this cryptic invitation to attend Christmas at a stranger’s house in England? What would you have done if you were Maggie?
We learn the mystery host is the world famous author, Eleanor Ashley. Why was Eleanor’s work so important to Maggie?
We learn about Maggie’s painful past, including losing her parents her first year of college, and also her husband left Maggie for her best friend. Let’s discuss Maggie’s past and how that impacted her present. How did this experience searching for Eleanor and developing feelings for Ethan help her move forward?
What did you think first happened to Eleanor when she went missing? Who did you suspect was behind her disappearance?
This story combines two genres: a locked-room mystery and a romance. What are your thoughts on blending genres? Do you prefer one genre over the other?
When did Maggie start to truly develop feelings for Ethan? Why was it important for us to know about Ethan’s past?
Did you enjoy their various adventures when searching for Eleanor?
Let’s talk about all the big reveals, including Dobson’s attempt to kill Eleanor and Maggie. And Eleanor faked her own death and disappeared. What were your thoughts about all of these reveals?
Did you like the ending and epilogue, including when Maggie and Ethan find Eleanor alive and living in Greece?
We never find out how Eleanor escaped. How do you think she got away?