Printable Book Club Questions for The Frozen River by Ariel Lawhon

Did you know much about Martha Ballard prior to reading this story? In what ways was Martha ahead of her time?
Why was becoming a midwife the right field for Martha? Also, why did Martha decide to keep a diary?
The central mystery in the story revolves around the fact a dead body was recovered in the river— a man named Burgess who was accused of rape by a local woman. What did you think happened to this man? Did that change as the story went on?
The woman, Rebecca, also accused a local judge, North, of rape. Martha helped Rebecca after the horrific attacks. Why didn’t Martha have Rebecca go to the authorities after it happened? Would there have been a different outcome if she had?
Why was it important for the audience to know that Martha herself had been raped, and that her rapist was eventually hung?
We get to know Martha and her family quite well, including her close relationship with her husband Ephraim. What was your impression of their relationship? Why did they work so well together?
While Rebecca’s case goes to court, North is acquitted of all charges. Eventually, he goes to attack Martha, and confesses everything, including the plan to illegally evict her family. In an act of self defense, Martha permanently wounds him. Let’s talk about this scene and Martha’s strength in the moment.
Should Martha have told the townspeople the truth of what North revealed? Or do you understand why she kept quiet about it?
It is eventually revealed that a man named Sam killed Burgress after catching Burgess assault Sam’s wife. Martha’s son Jonathan assisted him with this. Were you surprised at this reveal, or did you see it coming?
What did you think about the ending overall?
What was your impression of what life was like back in 1700s Maine?
Since publishing in 2024, this story has seen huge success, and is a big bestseller. Why do you think this story has resonated with so many people?